The material on this website is for information only
and is not intended as any recommendation or endorsement of any products or companies mentioned. We are not licensed by the FSA to give financial advice, and none of the material on this website constitutes or is intended to constitute financial ...
Financial TimesBig Indian banks inject funds to capitalise new UK subsidiariesFinancial TimesIt recently launched new Isa savings products and is moving into small business lending and buy-to-let mortgages. In deciding which foreign banks must comply with tougher rules, the BoE is weighing both the size of ... The UK rules partly stem from the ...and more »
This is MoneyHow to make sure a mortgage broker gets you the best dealThis is MoneyResearch shows that a lot of borrowers risk their family's future by skimping on life cover. To find an independent mortgage adviser or money expert try This is Money's carefully chosen partners or VouchedFor using the tool below.Don't be led astray by 0% credit cardsThe Independentall 2 news articles »
KiwiSaver: Tax shock for UK pension transfersNew Zealand HeraldEven if you leave the total transferred sum in your KiwiSaver account, funds withdrawn are considered to be taken from the UK pension and any withdrawal made within the relevant reporting period, including money taken to buy a first home, may incur a ...and more »
This is MoneyTread carefully in minefield of ultra-low fixed rate mortgage deals and avoid ...This is MoneyThe mortgage market is laden with offers – with ultra-low fixed rates and more attractive deals for buyers with small deposits driving a rise in new borrowing and remortgaging. Last week, Yorkshire Building Society alone reported a 70 per cent leap in ...Don't be led astray by 0% credit cardsThe Independentall 2 news articles »
Press TVUK super rich get low-interest mortgagesPress TV“The ordinary people are being pressed out of the housing market by this policy which gives to the already wealthy who use that money to increase their wealthy assets, none of which is tripling down to the ordinary people,” Rodney Shakespeare told ...
Have you met...
Latest Members:


Kathryn Moore



debra barnes




Jeremy Clarkson vs Eco Expert: Battle of the Hybrid Car Reviewers!

Jeremy Clarkson vs Eco Expert: Battle of the Hybrid Car Reviewers!

I would usually advocate that environmentalists take a non-confrontational approach. It’s usually unhelpful to set up an ‘us versus them’ dynamic. Besides, most moderate readers would conclude the truth is about half way in between, or that there’s a ‘third way’. Those people are wise. Nevertheless, I think Jeremy Clarkson needs challenging on his review of the Honda Insight, and I think framing it as an all out battle might help him to take notice! 

Clarkson starts his review skipping over the fuel efficiency of the new Honda Insight, the point of the car. He tries to brush off the benefits to the planet: “sure, you could get 60 or more mpg if you were careful. And that’s not bad for a spacious five-door hatchback.” He prefers to base his review on “what it’s like as a car” to drive.  

JC says: “It’s terrible. Biblically terrible.”

EE says: “It’s fine. Biblically fine.”

I have to wonder if Clarkson and I actually drove the same car. But we did. We both test drove the new Honda Insight 1.3 Hybrid, around mid 2009.

ecoexpert_logo.gifJC says: “It’s worse than the sound of your parachute failing to open. Really, to get an idea of how awful it is, you’d have to sit a dog on a ham slicer.”

EE says: “I couldn’t really hear the engine.” 

Now I have to apologise to my readers. My language above was not as amusing as Clarkson’s. Perhaps I should rephrase, you know, just for effect.

In_Gear_556559a.gifEE says: “It sounds better than your parachute opening and drifting serenely to a soft sand beach for a peaceful landing. Really, to get an idea of how peaceful it is, you’d have to inject a dog with a tranquiliser”.

I think I’ve made my point. Clarkson is known for his colourful over emphasis, but in this case, I believe it’s at the expense of accuracy, and the planet. The engine doesn’t make your ears bleed, the seats don’t ruin your skeleton, and the top speed is a lot more than 23mph. Clarkson, you’re exaggerating. And what’s worse, numerically inaccurate. Not that anyone would believe 23mph anyway. Clarkson therefore effectively admits to his own journalistic hyperbole.

The systematically unfounded rantings of a famous petrol head have a dark side when people base their buying decisions on them. That dark side is the 150,000 women, men and children who currently pay for global warming with their lives each year. Tell readers in China and India not to buy the Honda Insight, and you’re adding to climate change. Perhaps I should over emphasise my point here for effect, and depict an image of Clarkson issuing death warrants and licences to drown.

Yes I noticed that the Honda Insight 1.3 has slightly less power than a Ford Mondeo 2.0. But it felt similar to any other 1.3. I pulled away from a roundabout pretty sharpish, getting me out of sticky situation. If you want to tow a caravan, maybe you need a 2.0, but for most people the 1.3 is fine. 

We can at least try to say something is fine and be entertaining at the same time. How about we do a joint press release stating:

“If you want a normal family car that is “biblically fine”, buy the Honda Insight. It was built in Honda’s Fine Factory, designed by a team lead by Professor Fine of Fine University, Fineland.”

Atul Srivastava
Eco Expert
Follow my daily Twitter updates of Eco News:

Sources and thanks to:

Advertise with us  |  Privacy  |  Terms & Copyright                                                                                     Website maintained by USP Networks